2. ISLAMIC AND CHRISTIAN BELIEFS
Muslims and
Christians have a lot in common.
Thus, we find that the Christian belief system
is much
closer to that of the
Muslims, whereas significant
differences exist between Christians and
Islamic doctrines on the one hand and the Jewish creed
on
the other. In this respect, we shall first consider the common features of the teachings of Jesus Christ and
Prophet Muhammad (Peace
be upon them) and then we shall deal with five crucial points that
are shared by Christians
and Muslim.
A number of misunderstandings are prevalent
among Muslim scholars regarding the teachings of Prophet Jesus (Peace
be upon them) as
they appear in the four Gospels. Indeed,
if
one is to compare the teachings of the two religions
in
a superficial and casual
manner, he can no
doubt point out a number
of disagreements. However, a deeper study of the teachings of Prophet Jesus and Prophet Muhammad
(Peace be upon them) will reveal that there is no fundamental disharmony between
the two. This point needs to be elucidated, as follow.
The
methodology of Prophet Muhammad (Peace be
upon them)
-- in his struggle to bring about an Islamic
Revolution -- consisted of two distinct approaches. The first can be described as the primary or elementary approach which was employed by the
Prophet to assemble a group of highly dedicated, committed, and thoroughly trained men. The second one can be described
as the ultimate or the
final approach, which was employed
by the Prophet to make use of this group
in the actual confrontation or conflict with the guardians of the status
quo.
The primary or
elementary
approach of Prophet
Muhammad (Peace be upon them) can be understood
with the help
to four
Qur’anic terms. These are:
Recitation of the
Divine Revelations (Tilawat-e-Aayat), Purification of the
souls (Tazkiyya), Instructions regarding the Do’s and
the Don’ts (Taleem-e-Kitab), and the Inculcation of
wisdom
(Taleem-e-Hikmat). These terms appear at four different places in the Holy Qur’an (Al-Baqara 2:129 & 151; Aal-e- Imran 3:164; Al-Jum’ah 62:2), and represent the
four
dimensions of the fundamental duties of Prophet
Muhammad (Peace
be upon them).
It is significant to note that, among
the
previous Revelations, we find and interesting division with regard
to the different aspects
of
Divine Guidance.
That
is to say, the Torah
of Prophet
Moses contained only
the instructions regarding the do’s and the don’ts (Kitab), the Psalms of Prophet David was
composed only of hymns
of God the
Almighty
(Aayat),
and the
Gospel of Prophet
Jesus consisted predominantly of wisdom (Hikmat).
The
Holy Qur’an – being the last of divine Revelations -- is the
most comprehensive Book
in
that it contains
all
three elements of Divine Guidance, plus it is also the
source for purifying human hearts (Tazkiyya).
All apparent discrepancies between the teachings of Prophet Jesus and those of Prophet Muhammad (Peace
be upon them) are, in fact, a direct result of disregarding
the
crucial fact that the Gospels
deal primarily
with
the inner and esoteric element
of
Deen and not
with
its legal and formal aspects. Therefore, if one is to compare the teachings of the two
religions without losing sight of this fact, the apparent
inconsistencies
would ceases to disturb him, and he will soon realize that
both religions
actually teach the same
things, but from different perspectives.
The ultimate or the final approach
of Prophet Muhammad
(Peace be upon
them)
consisted
of two distinct phases: the struggle in Makkah,
which was characterized by passive Resistance, when the order
of
the day was to remain peaceful and
not to reliant under
any provocation whatsoever: and the struggle in Medina, which was characterized by Active Resistance,
and the accompanying armed conflict against the defenders of the
status quo, when the
believers were not only allowed
but were actually encouraged
and ordained to fight in the
way of Allah.
Some Muslim scholars have a
tendency to disparage the teaching of passivity that
is found
everywhere in the four Gospels, labeling it as unnatural and impracticable. However, this
issue
can be easily resolved if we
realize
that the instruction of Jesus Christ to “turn the other cheek” was
not
a permanent part of his message, but that he had
ordered his followers to remain
passive and
peaceful only till
the time when
they had
enough strength the challenge the unjust and ungodly system. This instruction is identical to
the order
of
Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon them) that was given by him to his Companions during the
phase
of
Passive Resistance in
Makkah. However, in contrast to the life of Prophet
Muhammad (Peace be upon them), we see that the stages
of
active resistance and armed conflict never arrived
in the brief career
of Prophet
Jesus
(Peace be upon them),
because Almighty Allah had raised
him up into the
heavens in
order to save him from
being
crucified. Muslims believer that, after
his
second coming, the Christ
will
lead the army of the
believers against the followers of
Dajjal, and that he will thus complete his
unfinished mission.